Skip to content
Explore trending topics and expert perspectives on UK media…

A United Ireland Plebiscite Must Not Become 'A Sequel to Brexit', Experts Alert

Ten years following the UK stumbled into a hasty referendum that split the country and unleashed chaos, a caution comes from beyond the Irish Sea: it may occur once more.

Authorities and electorate entered unwittingly Brexit and the identical could occur with a national vote on a united Ireland, initiating convulsions for which nobody is equipped.

That represents the warning from two leading commentators from each side of the Irish border who have collaborated to analyse the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland leaving the UK to create a fresh nation with the Republic of Ireland.

Administrative Structures Ill-Equipped

Fintan O’Toole and Sam McBride, have determined that the government bodies in Ireland and Britain are woefully unready for a possibly fraught and monumental public vote.

"The lesson of Brexit has gone unabsorbed, which is that events can come out of the blue and can build support very quickly," the commentator said. "It is my view that the institutional structure of our region remains very unstable."

New Title Aims to Encourage Dialogue

The pair have studied the political, financial and societal arguments for any structural alteration in a publication, The Case For and Against Unification, published by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.

They seek to encourage dialogue on the topic with a roadshow of speaking events that will lead them to Westminster early next month.

"What concerns all parties, or ought to concern all involved, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," commented O’Toole.

"We do not want a referendum on a thumbs up-thumbs down, ambiguous question whose consequences have not been clarified because then you end up with an extremely split population where those defeated are unable to accept losing and the victorious side are uncertain exactly what it is that they have won."

Governmental Mandate

Under the peace accord, the Northern Ireland secretary of state is obliged to schedule a public vote on Irish unification if it is indicated that a majority would support.

Nationalist parties and other pro-unification groups argue such a time is looming, and a group named pro-unification advocates has garnered backing, but both governments and pro-UK factions play down the possibility, making it uncertain when or if there could be a referendum.

Insufficient Serious Debate

Ideological statements supporting and opposing unity has obscured the absence of substantive discussion, said McBride.

"Many are supportive or opposed the notion but the detailed consideration which might go beyond that to realise it has largely not occurred. A great deal has gone on in scholarly circles but very few elected officials or advocates want to engage even with the fundamentals. To illustrate, what type of nation should be desired? Unitary? Federal?"

Publication's Method

In the volume, no writer advocates unity or the status quo. Each composes two essays that seek objectivity in laying out the case for a united Ireland and the argument opposing it, assembling economic and societal figures, past examples and structural examples.

Arguments encompass national emblems, levies, health services, pensions, public liabilities and the threat of loyalist violence. The goal is to enlighten and stimulate dialogue.

"Considerable attention exists in the subject but there is still lacking a debate," said the writer. "Debate indicates an recognition of the concept that there could be reasonable perspectives on both sides."

Simultaneous Plebiscites

A public vote in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the Republic of Ireland, where citizens say they favour unity but oppose paying higher taxes or introducing a alternative symbol to reflect pro-UK communities' British identity.

"The Irish government should work out what the proposal from nationalist groups is aside from just saying: 'We desire a unified Ireland and we welcome you'," said the commentator.

Probability of Referendum

McBride believes a national vote in his era is likely and that it might occur suddenly. "There might be just a irresponsible or a bad or a negligent secretary of state who says: 'Let's just do this and settle the matter.'"

Both nationalists and pro-UK supporters have reasonable, valid points, he said. "One side will prevail on this issue and the other side will in the end be defeated but all factions has has something to acquire from the other's viewpoints."

Request for Wider Debate

Westminster needed to engage with the discussion, said O’Toole. "This involves your state. It's a British issue just as much as it is an Irish question."

Written by

Emma Castillo

A digital strategist with over a decade in media innovation, focusing on emerging trends in UK journalism and content creation.

Blog Central Media

Type to search articles.